News On Japan

Whistleblowers Face Multimillion-Yen Lawsuits

TOKYO - Whistleblowers who expose suspected wrongdoing at companies and other organizations in Japan are increasingly finding themselves targeted by multimillion-yen damages claims, raising questions over whether the country's legal system adequately protects people who report misconduct.

Those facing lawsuits say the claims are intended as retaliation or an attempt to silence them. Cases involving demands exceeding 20 million yen and approaching 50 million yen have imposed severe financial and psychological burdens, even though Japan's Whistleblower Protection Act is intended to protect people who disclose wrongdoing in the public interest.

One case involves the operator of Momuri, a resignation agency that attracted widespread attention for helping workers leave their jobs. Investigators searched the company's offices after allegations that it had violated the Attorneys Act, with information from former employees among the factors that brought the case to light.

Former company president Shinji Tanimoto has been charged with violating the Attorneys Act and admitted the charge in court, saying he deeply regretted engaging in such conduct in a high-profile business providing resignation services.

At the same time, however, litigation has been proceeding against people involved in exposing misconduct at the company.

Nozomi Fukuda, 25, worked for the Momuri operating company for eight months last year. She said that while she was employed there, she was instructed to refer clients to lawyers and was told that the company would receive 16,500 yen for each referral.

According to Fukuda, she was also warned not to tell anyone outside the company because the arrangement was illegal.

Resignation agencies notify employers on behalf of clients that they intend to quit. Momuri's operator referred clients seeking to resign to affiliated lawyers and allegedly received compensation for those referrals.

Japanese law prohibits people without attorney qualifications from referring legal business to lawyers for profit.

Fukuda said the company had made such referrals part of its business despite knowing the practice was prohibited. Recorded discussions showed questions being raised about whether the company could receive around 30% of fees, while a lawyer explained that paying a referral fee was prohibited under the Attorneys Act but suggested compensation equivalent to that amount could potentially be provided under another name.

After confirming that payments had actually been made, Fukuda concluded that illegal conduct was occurring. She resigned four months later and reported the matter to organizations including a bar association.

Another former employee who joined Fukuda in making disclosures also posted online about alleged illegal conduct and suspected harassment within the company.

The company subsequently announced that it would sue three people. About two months later, Fukuda received court documents.

The Momuri operating company and Tanimoto alleged that online statements concerning harassment were false and sought 22 million yen in damages. Their lawsuit did not address the allegations concerning violations of the Attorneys Act.

Fukuda said the litigation transformed her life. While raising a child, she had to devote time to gathering evidence and dealing with the lawsuit, cutting into time with her family.

The pressure eventually became so severe that she suffered a cerebral infarction. She also found it increasingly difficult to manage family life and later divorced her husband.

The effects of her illness continue, while the lawsuit with the company remains unresolved.

Asked whether she would have taken part in the whistleblowing had she known how much time and money the litigation would consume, Fukuda said she was no longer certain.

"When I think about my child and my life, I might not have participated," she said.

Asked about the purpose of the lawsuit, the Momuri operating company said it would refrain from commenting because the matter was being contested in court.

A request for an interview with Tanimoto was made through a relative and his attorney earlier in August, but no response had been received.

Japan's Whistleblower Protection Act was enacted in 2004 to protect people who report organizational misconduct.

The law contains provisions intended to prevent companies from seeking damages simply because a whistleblower made a protected report. However, companies may still bring lawsuits if they cite reasons other than the act of whistleblowing itself.

That has prompted concern over so-called retaliatory lawsuits, in which litigation may be brought primarily to silence or pressure people rather than to establish the truth of a dispute.

Calls have been made for stronger legal restrictions, but the government has pointed to a constitutional dilemma. Freedom of speech and expression supports the protection of whistleblowers, while the Constitution also guarantees access to the courts.

Because the right to bring a lawsuit is itself constitutionally protected, restricting litigation even when it appears retaliatory requires careful consideration.

The issue remains unresolved, leaving lawmakers to consider how far legal safeguards should extend.

Critics argue that companies can absorb the cost of filing lawsuits seeking tens of millions of yen in damages far more easily than individual defendants. If litigation succeeds in silencing a whistleblower, they say, a company may regard the legal expense as worthwhile.

Another case illustrates the scale of that imbalance.

Yutaka Kato was an accounting manager at medical device maker STAAR Japan when he reported suspected bribery involving the company.

Former executives were later issued summary orders and fined over allegations that 600,000 yen in cash had been given to a hospital doctor in connection with the use of the company's surgical lenses for cataract treatment in 2023.

Kato said he learned about the questionable payments during an internal company meeting.

He raised concerns that the payments could constitute bribery, but said his objections were ignored and that he was excluded from subsequent meetings.

According to police investigation records and other material, the company later provided money to a doctor in return for supplying surgical video footage.

Kato said he decided to make a public-interest disclosure because patients could potentially be affected. In one case, a doctor who received money allegedly used the company's lens even though a different manufacturer's lens had already been implanted in the patient's other eye, creating a difference in color perception.

The company did not sue Kato over the act of whistleblowing itself. Instead, it sought approximately 50 million yen in damages over his removal of company data used to support the disclosure.

Because legal fees rise with the amount being claimed, Kato said his litigation costs have reached around 10 million yen, some of which he has still been unable to pay.

After about 18 months of proceedings, a court ruled that his removal of the information had been conducted for the purpose of making a public-interest disclosure and rejected the company's damages claim.

About a week after the ruling, however, the company appealed.

Kato's legal team has argued that the appeal makes clear the case is intended as harassment or retaliation against the company whistleblower.

The dispute has now continued for about two years.

Asked why it appealed, STAAR Japan said through its attorney that it would refrain from commenting.

Kato said that even if one damages lawsuit ends, another can follow, leaving him uncertain about where the litigation will ultimately lead.

"When I think about where this ends, either the company disappears or I do," he said.

The cases highlight the disparity between individuals and corporations in their ability to devote money, staff and time to prolonged litigation. Whistleblowers can be forced to spend years defending themselves while their personal lives and finances deteriorate.

Under Japan's current legal framework, preventing the filing of an allegedly retaliatory lawsuit itself remains difficult.

Legal experts say courts could nevertheless do more to reduce the burden on whistleblowers by promptly rejecting cases that lack legitimate grounds or constitute an abuse of the judicial process.

Kato said he hopes Japan becomes a society in which people considering public-interest disclosures can speak out without fearing retaliation.

The cases have exposed what critics describe as a significant gap in Japan's whistleblower protection system: while the law protects the act of reporting wrongdoing, it does not necessarily shield whistleblowers from lengthy and costly litigation brought on other grounds.

Source: YOMIURI

News On Japan
POPULAR NEWS

A bear believed to be a mother that has been roaming residential neighborhoods in Maebashi, Gunma Prefecture, since November 17 was spotted again by a police officer early on November 21, prompting authorities to prepare for its capture as residents entered a three-day holiday weekend following days of repeated sightings, school closures and a frightening encounter involving a high school student.

Residents of Okinawa's remote islands are struggling to secure airline tickets as travelers seeking to accumulate loyalty points flood short-haul flights, with some boarding as many as 12 planes a day without stopping to sightsee, leaving essential routes fully booked and prompting calls for Japan Airlines (JAL) to reconsider its promotional campaign.

Traditional matchmaking is making a comeback in Japan as younger generations increasingly seek safer and more efficient ways to find marriage partners, with growing frustration over dating apps encouraging a return to arranged introductions once common among their parents and grandparents.

Nepalese police have detained 35 Japanese nationals and five Chinese nationals suspected of involvement in organized fraud operations at a mountain resort hotel near Kathmandu, where the group had allegedly established a sophisticated base equipped with a mock police station, photography studios and dozens of livestreaming booths.

A powerful surge of midwinter cold air is bringing heavy snow, strong winds and freezing temperatures to much of Japan ahead of the three-day holiday weekend beginning November 21st, with authorities warning of dangerous road conditions, possible landslides and traffic disruptions as snow and heavy rain continue along the Sea of Japan coast through the morning of November 22nd.

MEDIA CHANNELS
         

MORE Business NEWS

US artificial intelligence developer Anthropic made its Nasdaq debut on November 19, with its shares finishing 17% above their offering price despite sharp declines in Japanese and American technology stocks, highlighting growing concerns that the enormous investments driving the AI boom may be outpacing the industry's ability to generate sustainable profits.

Honda unveiled its new Avancier SUV on November 20th, marking its entry into the large SUV segment with a three-row hybrid model scheduled to go on sale in Japan in spring 2027 as part of a broader effort to revive its automobile business.

Japan's rice harvest is expected to remain at a high level in 2026 despite prolonged rainfall and insufficient sunshine in some regions, with the Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries announcing on November 20 that production of rice for direct consumption is projected to reach 7.365 million tons.

Japan's Nikkei 225 plunged 3,008 points, or 5.06%, to close at 56,437 on Friday, November 20, its lowest level in more than seven months, as a global selloff in artificial intelligence and semiconductor stocks swept through Tokyo following a disappointing market reaction to Anthropic's initial public offering in the United States, triggering widespread selling that extended to banks, consumer stocks and other major industries.

Japan Tobacco (JT) has announced that it will exclude seven companies involved in its Russian operations from its consolidated financial statements after the Russian government placed the businesses under temporary administration, with the Japanese tobacco giant expecting to record losses of approximately 1.377 trillion yen.

Tokyo stocks closed higher on Thursday, November 19, 2026, with the Nikkei 225 gaining 419.93 points, or 0.71%, to finish at 59,444.21 at the 3:30 p.m. close, extending its rebound for a second consecutive session as expectations surrounding the record-breaking initial public offering of U.S. artificial intelligence developer Anthropic supported selected technology shares, although declines in Nvidia, copper prices and smaller growth stocks exposed continuing weakness across the broader market.

Japan's core machinery orders fell 0.3% in September from the previous month to 1.0662 trillion yen, marking the first decline in two months, although the government maintained its assessment that orders are showing signs of recovery.

Japan's Nikkei 225 rebounded on November 18 after two consecutive days of losses, closing 163.85 points higher, or 0.28%, at 59,024.28 at 3:30 p.m. Tokyo time, although an early rally driven by strong earnings from U.S. chipmaker Nvidia quickly lost momentum, leaving investors cautious about the outlook for artificial intelligence, technology valuations and the broader economy.