News On Japan

Is Japan’s low COVID-19 death rate due to a 'higher cultural level'?

Jun 13, 2020 (Japan Times) - I was sent scrambling for my dictionary on June 4 when Finance Minister Taro Aso declared that the different "mindo" between Japan and other countries was the reason behind Japan’s low COVID-19 death rate.

A quintessentially nebulous Japanese word, mindo denotes the standard of living and cultural level of a people, and can variously be used to refer to a population’s degree of maturity in terms of intellectual, educational, and cultural levels, or behaviors.

The word "mindo" was created during the Meiji Ea (1868-1912), a time when Japan became interested in comparing itself with other countries. Inherent in it is a sense of judgement about which populations’ “level” or “standards” are higher or lower. Scholar Michael Kim notes that during the colonization of Korea, “The Japanese deployed the mindo concept frequently to justify their unequal colonial policies and explain their rationale for excluding Koreans from the welfare and educational policies instituted in Japan proper.” Last week, television personality Dave Spector said that he had been told never to use the term on air.

Assailed over the use of this loaded term, Aso later explained that he didn’t mean to put down “other countries,” but rather to point out that, unlike Japan, they were unable to keep their death rates down despite using coercion, and that the Japanese should be proud of how they cooperated with social distancing requests that were more gentle.

For many Japanese, Japan’s low death per capita rate from COVID-19 in comparison to many other industrialized countries has indeed become a point of pride — one that is not necessarily misplaced. Initially, many observers were worried that Japan would have a much higher death toll than it currently has. With its high proportion of elderly residents and densely packed cities — combined with little polymerase chain reaction (PCR) testing and a reluctance to impose harsh lockdowns — it seemed that Japan might end up looking like hard-hit areas such as northern Italy or New York. Fortunately, though, that grim scenario did not materialize.

The resulting relief and pride have fostered a sense of exceptionalism. Nobel laureate Shinya Yamanaka has hypothesized an as-yet-unknown “Factor X” that accounts for Japan’s low death rate. Explanations of Japan’s success have been various, with Prime Minister Shinzo Abe lauding an undefined “Japan model,” the vice chairman of Japan’s coronavirus expert panel Shigeru Omi citing hygiene practices such as wearing masks and washing hands, and commentator Yoshiko Sakurai, in echoes of Aso’s use of mindo, praising “the Japanese people’s higher public health consciousness, moral values, and sense of solidarity to overcome adversity.” One Japanese blogger listed 43 different theories that have been circulating.

It is important to keep in mind, however, which “other countries” Japan’s low death rate is being compared to. As of Tuesday, according to data website Worldometer, Japan has had 7 deaths per 1 million population from COVID-19. That number indeed looks excellent in comparison to some of the hardest hit countries, such as Belgium with 829, the United Kingdom with 598, Spain with 580 and Italy with 562.

On the other hand, there are quite a few countries with lower death rates than Japan’s. They include South Korea with 5 per 1 million; Singapore, Malaysia, New Zealand and Australia with 4; Thailand with 0.8; Taiwan with 0.3 and both Vietnam and Mongolia with zero. I wonder, would Aso say that that all those countries have higher mindo than Japan?

News On Japan
POPULAR NEWS

A bear believed to be a mother that has been roaming residential neighborhoods in Maebashi, Gunma Prefecture, since November 17 was spotted again by a police officer early on November 21, prompting authorities to prepare for its capture as residents entered a three-day holiday weekend following days of repeated sightings, school closures and a frightening encounter involving a high school student.

Residents of Okinawa's remote islands are struggling to secure airline tickets as travelers seeking to accumulate loyalty points flood short-haul flights, with some boarding as many as 12 planes a day without stopping to sightsee, leaving essential routes fully booked and prompting calls for Japan Airlines (JAL) to reconsider its promotional campaign.

Traditional matchmaking is making a comeback in Japan as younger generations increasingly seek safer and more efficient ways to find marriage partners, with growing frustration over dating apps encouraging a return to arranged introductions once common among their parents and grandparents.

Nepalese police have detained 35 Japanese nationals and five Chinese nationals suspected of involvement in organized fraud operations at a mountain resort hotel near Kathmandu, where the group had allegedly established a sophisticated base equipped with a mock police station, photography studios and dozens of livestreaming booths.

A powerful surge of midwinter cold air is bringing heavy snow, strong winds and freezing temperatures to much of Japan ahead of the three-day holiday weekend beginning November 21st, with authorities warning of dangerous road conditions, possible landslides and traffic disruptions as snow and heavy rain continue along the Sea of Japan coast through the morning of November 22nd.

MEDIA CHANNELS
         

MORE Society NEWS

Princess Aiko, the only daughter of Emperor Naruhito and Empress Masako, visited Singapore's famous Lau Pa Sat Hawker Center on November 20, experiencing the city-state's diverse food culture after planting a tree symbolizing happiness at a Japanese garden associated with her grandparents, former Emperor Akihito and former Empress Michiko.

Nepalese police have detained 35 Japanese nationals and five Chinese nationals suspected of involvement in organized fraud operations at a mountain resort hotel near Kathmandu, where the group had allegedly established a sophisticated base equipped with a mock police station, photography studios and dozens of livestreaming booths.

A bear chased a high school student riding a bicycle through a residential neighborhood in Maebashi, Gunma Prefecture, on November 19th, prompting a large-scale police search amid concerns that the animal may be the parent of a cub captured two days earlier.

A 38-year-old home care worker has been arrested on suspicion of arson and attempted murder after allegedly setting fire to the Tokyo apartment of a man in his 50s who required nursing care, telling investigators he wanted to avoid further visits after being repeatedly insulted by the patient.

Princess Aiko, the only daughter of Emperor Naruhito and Empress Masako, attended a ceremony in Singapore on November 19 at which a new orchid variety was named in her honor, marking the third day of her official visit to the country.

The Osaka District Court on November 18 ordered a hospital to pay 220,000 yen in compensation after a 12-centimeter metal key was discovered lodged in the throat of an 82-year-old patient who died several days later, ruling that the hospital had failed to properly manage the key but rejecting claims that the incident caused his death.

A 31-year-old man nicknamed "Spider-Man" by police investigators has been arrested on suspicion of stealing jewelry worth approximately 25 million yen from a shopping complex in Moriya, Ibaraki Prefecture, after hiding among clothing displays until the facility closed.

A 36-year-old woman arrested on suspicion of defrauding a former high school classmate of approximately 25 million yen by falsely claiming that spilled alcohol had caused extensive damage to company housing has admitted to the allegations, telling investigators she wanted to buy gifts for her husband and win praise from her mother and friends.