News On Japan

CVC Capital's bid for Toshiba exposes pervasive conflicts of interest

Apr 13, 2021 (Nikkei) - The reported $20 billion bid to take Toshiba private from U.K.-based private equity fund CVC Capital Partners has the investment community abuzz: Will CEO Nobuaki Kurumatani actually be allowed to pull it off and escape the nets that are encircling him?

There is no way the timing of CVC's offer, on the heels of a shareholder vote to appoint independent investigators to review alleged vote tampering at last year's annual general meeting, is a coincidence.

A going private transaction -- if it can be accomplished quickly enough -- will effectively shut down the investigation and leave the world forever guessing at whether Kurumatani and other members of Toshiba senior management engaged in misconduct. It will also relieve Kurumatani from having to face reelection at the coming AGM in June, after having eked out a slim 57% margin at last year's contested AGM.

The identity of the bidder is a further reason for raised eyebrows. CEO Kurumatani served as President of CVC's Japan unit immediately prior to assuming office at Toshiba. Kurumatani's confidant and former Lixil CEO, Yoshiaki Fujimori, currently serves as a Toshiba director and special adviser to CVC.

Given the context and relationships, it seems unlikely that CVC's bid came out of the blue. The more plausible scenario is that it was solicited by Kurumatani to save his own skin. At one end of the spectrum of possibilities, one can imagine a tacit quid pro quo between Kurumatani and his former employer: a senior management role and equity in the privatized entity for Kurumatani in exchange for his help steering the deal in CVC's direction at a favorable buyout price.

The conflicts of interest between Toshiba management and shareholders are palpable. Yet Toshiba has shown itself remarkably tone-deaf to conflicts. To take the most recent example, Toshiba's shareholders voted for an independent investigation of last year's AGM in large part because the internal review by audit committee members who themselves were candidates in the contested election raised more questions than it answered.

How Toshiba addresses the obvious conflicts will be a fascinating test of the current condition of corporate governance in Japan. As a threshold issue, will Kurumatani and Fujimori be required to recuse themselves from negotiating with CVC? Will the terms of any compensation or equity participation for them in a privatized Toshiba be fully disclosed and vetted for fairness by a reliably objective process?

Even more significant and complex, will Toshiba take the CVC bid as the occasion to put itself up for auction to the highest bidder, one that may not be interested in Kuramatani's services post-acquisition? The conventional corporate law answer, echoed in the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry's own fair M&A guidelines, is that competing bids should be invited to ensure shareholders get the best price possible.

But whether Toshiba should be put on the block for auction is complicated by the fact that it is a designated national security asset. Sale to a foreign fund like CVC will require METI's approval under the Foreign Exchange and Foreign Trade ACT (FEFTA).

That METI itself will necessarily play a deciding role in Toshiba's fate puts in the headlights METI's split personality as it relates to corporate governance generally and to Toshiba in particular.

News On Japan
POPULAR NEWS

A bear believed to be a mother that has been roaming residential neighborhoods in Maebashi, Gunma Prefecture, since November 17 was spotted again by a police officer early on November 21, prompting authorities to prepare for its capture as residents entered a three-day holiday weekend following days of repeated sightings, school closures and a frightening encounter involving a high school student.

Residents of Okinawa's remote islands are struggling to secure airline tickets as travelers seeking to accumulate loyalty points flood short-haul flights, with some boarding as many as 12 planes a day without stopping to sightsee, leaving essential routes fully booked and prompting calls for Japan Airlines (JAL) to reconsider its promotional campaign.

Traditional matchmaking is making a comeback in Japan as younger generations increasingly seek safer and more efficient ways to find marriage partners, with growing frustration over dating apps encouraging a return to arranged introductions once common among their parents and grandparents.

Nepalese police have detained 35 Japanese nationals and five Chinese nationals suspected of involvement in organized fraud operations at a mountain resort hotel near Kathmandu, where the group had allegedly established a sophisticated base equipped with a mock police station, photography studios and dozens of livestreaming booths.

A powerful surge of midwinter cold air is bringing heavy snow, strong winds and freezing temperatures to much of Japan ahead of the three-day holiday weekend beginning November 21st, with authorities warning of dangerous road conditions, possible landslides and traffic disruptions as snow and heavy rain continue along the Sea of Japan coast through the morning of November 22nd.

MEDIA CHANNELS
         

MORE Society NEWS

Princess Aiko, the only daughter of Emperor Naruhito and Empress Masako, visited Singapore's famous Lau Pa Sat Hawker Center on November 20, experiencing the city-state's diverse food culture after planting a tree symbolizing happiness at a Japanese garden associated with her grandparents, former Emperor Akihito and former Empress Michiko.

Nepalese police have detained 35 Japanese nationals and five Chinese nationals suspected of involvement in organized fraud operations at a mountain resort hotel near Kathmandu, where the group had allegedly established a sophisticated base equipped with a mock police station, photography studios and dozens of livestreaming booths.

A bear chased a high school student riding a bicycle through a residential neighborhood in Maebashi, Gunma Prefecture, on November 19th, prompting a large-scale police search amid concerns that the animal may be the parent of a cub captured two days earlier.

A 38-year-old home care worker has been arrested on suspicion of arson and attempted murder after allegedly setting fire to the Tokyo apartment of a man in his 50s who required nursing care, telling investigators he wanted to avoid further visits after being repeatedly insulted by the patient.

Princess Aiko, the only daughter of Emperor Naruhito and Empress Masako, attended a ceremony in Singapore on November 19 at which a new orchid variety was named in her honor, marking the third day of her official visit to the country.

The Osaka District Court on November 18 ordered a hospital to pay 220,000 yen in compensation after a 12-centimeter metal key was discovered lodged in the throat of an 82-year-old patient who died several days later, ruling that the hospital had failed to properly manage the key but rejecting claims that the incident caused his death.

A 31-year-old man nicknamed "Spider-Man" by police investigators has been arrested on suspicion of stealing jewelry worth approximately 25 million yen from a shopping complex in Moriya, Ibaraki Prefecture, after hiding among clothing displays until the facility closed.

A 36-year-old woman arrested on suspicion of defrauding a former high school classmate of approximately 25 million yen by falsely claiming that spilled alcohol had caused extensive damage to company housing has admitted to the allegations, telling investigators she wanted to buy gifts for her husband and win praise from her mother and friends.