Homelessness, social stigma, and fringes of Japanese society

At best, they are considered a nuisance, an eyesore, and at worst they are harassed or attacked for being in public spaces like in Gifu Prefecture where five teens were arrested for assaulting and murdering a homeless man this April. When Typhoon Hagibis hit Tokyo last year on October 12, three homeless men were refused entry to an emergency evacuation center in Taito Ward because they did not have a fixed address in the area. Now, amidst the COVID-19 pandemic, the homeless are again bearing the brunt of the crisis, as they cannot “stay home” or “social distance” to protect themselves from the virus. The lingering question is: What is being done about it?

Controversial numbers: How many homeless in Japan?

According to a national survey conducted in January 2017 by the Ministry of Health, Labor, and Welfare, there are approximately 5,534 homeless in Japan, with 5,168 being men, and 196 being women. Tokyo had the highest homeless population of 1,397. The accuracy of these numbers, however, is questionable. An independent survey conducted in 2019 by a citizen’s group operating in Tokyo found 2.8 times more homeless people than the figures presented by the Tokyo Metropolitan Government. The group, known as the Advocacy and Research Centre for the Homeless (ARCH), have conducted their own surveys since 2016, with each one finding the number of homeless to be higher than those suggested officially.

The discrepancy stems from the Tokyo Metropolitan Government surveying during the day, while ARCH conducted their surveys at night. This time difference is significant, as the homeless are more likely to be out of sight during the day, either working or walking in search of facilities. Nighttime is much more crucial in determining the number of homeless as they are likely to be in one place, resting. Such controversial numbers contribute to the idea that the Japanese government is downplaying the severity of homelessness in Japan, and indeed, there was little discussion of specific measures taken to address the issue of how COVID-19 is affecting the homeless.

The effect of COVID-19 on the homeless

Takayuki Koda, a 67 year old homeless man, told the Japan Times that the “Coronavirus is an illness for pampered people”. He believes this because there have been no reports of the homeless dying from the virus, so people like him have anything to worry about. The reality however, is that the homeless are at a much higher risk of contracting the COVID-19, and many of them have prior health issues like diabetes and heart disease. This prompted Professor David H. Slater of Sophia University to call on the government to open the currently unused Olympic stadiums as a shelter for the homeless as an easy and necessary next step. Unfortunately, there have been no reports of this taking place. Instead, the government decided to provide a 100,000 yen virus relief fund to everyone currently residing in Japan, including the homeless. But the homeless, with no fixed address, also have trouble obtaining the cash payout, as proof of residency is a prerequisite for receiving the money.

Long-term residents of Internet cafes also fall under the umbrella of the “homeless”, as they do not have a fixed address. Concerns over COVID-19 forced many to move out of these facilities when they were asked to close. Temporary housing was provided for some in business hotels, but there weren’t enough rooms to accommodate everyone. The aim of this hotel support scheme is to encourage a visit to the welfare office for consultation – something many homeless individuals find difficult to do. Japanese society traditionally places emphasis on self-reliance, and welfare is only given to those whose families cannot support them. Thus, seeking welfare would amount to a shameful confession of personal failure.